Most date labels are about flavor and freshness, not safety, and only infant formula carries a federally required date. Here’s what each phrase actually means.
In brief
- Except for infant formula, date labels on US food are voluntary and describe quality, not safety; the FDA and USDA don’t require them.
- ‘Best if used by’ means peak flavor, ‘sell by’ is a store inventory tool, and ‘use by’ is the manufacturer’s last date for peak quality.
- Food past its date is usually safe to eat if it was stored and handled properly and shows no signs of spoilage.
- The average American household wastes about $1,500 of food a year, and confusion over date labels contributes roughly 20% of household food waste.
- A refrigerator thermometer and the USDA’s FoodKeeper app take the guesswork out of how long food keeps.
A date stamped on a carton of milk or a box of crackers feels official, like a deadline set by someone who knows exactly when the food stops being safe. In most cases, it isn’t. Except for infant formula, the dates on American food labels describe quality, not safety, and the federal government doesn’t require them at all. Learning what those phrases actually say is an easy step toward throwing away less food and spending less at the grocery store.
Why food carries dates in the first place
The Food and Drug Administration and the U.S. Department of Agriculture do not require dates on most food. Manufacturers add them voluntarily, as long as the information is truthful and not misleading. Some states and local governments have their own dating rules, and such rules exist in at least 41 states, but the exact requirements and wording are far from uniform.
The dates exist mostly to help stores manage inventory and to signal when food will taste its best. They are the manufacturer’s estimate, not a safety verdict. The USDA has encouraged the industry to use the phrase “Best if used by” because research shows shoppers read it as a statement about freshness rather than safety, which is exactly how it should be read.
The labels you’ll see and what each one means
Packaging usually carries one of two kinds of dates. Open dates are calendar dates paired with a phrase such as “sell by” or “best by,” and they appear mostly on perishable foods like meat and dairy. Closed dates are production codes, often on cans and boxes, that tell the manufacturer when the product was made.
The four phrases you’re most likely to see work like this:
| Label | Who it’s really for | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| Best if used by | Shoppers | Last date for peak flavor and quality. Not a purchase or safety date. |
| Sell by | Stores | How long to display the product for inventory management. Not a safety date. |
| Use by | Shoppers | Last date the product is at peak quality, per the manufacturer. A safety deadline only on infant formula. |
| Freeze by | Shoppers | When to freeze the food to maintain peak quality. |
You may also see a note such as “use within X days of opening.” That one touches both quality and safety, because food is more likely to pick up contamination after the package has been opened and exposed to air, utensils and other foods.
An illustration, using milk: a gallon marked “sell by June 10” is not unsafe on June 11. Stored at or below 40°F, it can stay fine to drink for roughly 5 to 7 days after that date. The sell-by date was a message to the store, not to you.
The one product with a federally required date
Infant formula is the exception. Federal law requires a “use by” date on every container, and formula should not be used after it. The reason is not spoilage in the usual sense. Over time, formula can lose nutrients and may no longer contain the amounts listed on the label, so the date guarantees both nutrient content and acceptable quality up to the point printed on the package.
Is it safe to eat food past its date?
For everything else, the answer is usually yes, provided the food has been stored and handled properly. The FDA has said that foods showing no signs of spoilage should still be wholesome and can be sold, purchased, donated and eaten past their “best by” date.
The confusion is widespread. A report from the Natural Resources Defense Council and the Harvard Food Law and Policy Clinic found that about 80 percent of Americans toss food out early over confusion about what the dates mean. In a Harvard survey, 84 percent of people said they throw food away past its date at least occasionally, and more than a third said they always toss food that is close to or past its date. The same survey showed the mix-up: 70 percent of people correctly read “best if used by” as a quality claim, but only 40 percent read “use by” that way, while 42 percent thought it was about safety.
One honest caveat: mishandled perishable food can be unsafe while looking and smelling perfectly normal. That risk comes from storage and handling, not from the calendar date on the package.
How to judge whether food has actually gone bad
Your senses do most of the work. If food looks bad, smells bad or has an off texture, don’t eat it. Spoilage bacteria, the kind that make milk sour and leftovers slimy, change how food looks and smells, so they announce themselves.
Pathogenic bacteria, the kind that cause foodborne illness, are the harder problem. They can grow in food without changing its appearance or odor, which is why safe handling matters more than any printed date. Keep perishables cold, respect the “use within X days of opening” notes on packages, and check the USDA’s FoodKeeper guidance when you’re unsure how long something has been good after opening.
Storage habits that keep food good longer
How food is stored determines how long it stays good, date or no date. A few habits pay off:
- Keep an appliance thermometer in the refrigerator and freezer to confirm they’re running properly.
- Follow the USDA’s FoodKeeper app or website, which lists storage times for the pantry, refrigerator and freezer, including how long foods keep after opening.
- Freeze food you won’t eat in time. A “freeze by” date is a quality guide, and freezing meets it.
- Use older packages first and put newer ones behind them in the fridge and pantry.
Try this: A refrigerator thermometer takes the guesswork out of cold storage. If your fridge isn’t holding its temperature, food can sour well before any date on the package.
What this means for your grocery bill and food waste
Households pay for this confusion in real dollars. The USDA Economic Research Service has estimated that the average American household wastes about $1,500 worth of food each year, and government agencies have estimated that confusion over date labels contributes roughly 20 percent of household food waste. Nationwide, an estimated 160 billion pounds of food goes to waste annually, and much of it was fine to eat.
The labels themselves are starting to change. California signed Assembly Bill 660 into law in September 2024, and starting July 1, 2026 it will require standard wording statewide: “Best if Used By” for quality dates and “Use By” for safety-related dates, with consumer-facing “sell by” labels prohibited. Federal agencies have been encouraging the industry to adopt similar wording voluntarily, so dates should get easier to read over time.
In the meantime, treat dates as quality estimates, store food well and trust your senses. For more ways to keep groceries out of the trash, see how to waste less food at home, and for scraps you can’t save, home composting basics explains how to turn them into garden soil.
Reader questions
Can I eat food after the "best if used by" date?
In most cases, yes. The date is about flavor and quality, and the FDA says foods without signs of spoilage can be eaten, donated or sold past it, as long as they have been stored and handled properly.
What if baby formula is past its "use by" date?
Don’t use it. Infant formula is the only food with a federally required date, and past that date it may no longer contain the nutrients listed on the label.
Why does milk sometimes go sour before the date on the carton?
Date labels assume proper storage. If a refrigerator runs warm or the carton sat out, spoilage bacteria grow faster and the printed date stops meaning much.
Are "sell by" dates going away?
Not nationwide yet, but change is underway. Starting July 1, 2026, California will require "Best if Used By" for quality dates and "Use By" for safety dates, and will bar consumer-facing "sell by" labels in the state.
This article is general information, not financial, legal or tax advice. Programs, incentives and rules change, so check current details with official sources and qualified professionals before you decide.
